By GM Ulvi Bajarani, Founder and Head Coach of Azeri Chess Academy.
You win your last game and finish with 4 points out of 5. Another player also finishes on 4, but the standings put that player first and you second. Did the tournament director give someone an extra point? No. You tied on game points. The tournament then used a tie-break to decide how to order the tied players.
The interesting part is that two legitimate tie-break methods can put those same players in opposite orders. The difference is what each method measures: the final scores of your opponents, the results you earned against them, the rounds in which you scored, or the games between the tied players.
#1 — Read the standings in the right order
Read the Score column first. A player with 4½ finishes ahead of a player with 4, regardless of their tie-break numbers. Among the players on 4, read TB1, the first announced tie-break. Use TB2 only for those still tied after TB1, and continue as needed. You do not add TB1 and TB2 together. The column headers tell you the order, not the formula. TB1 might mean Buchholz in one event and Direct Encounter in another.
Three questions belong to different stages of the event:
- Pairings: Who will I play next? See how chess tournament pairings work.
- Standings: If we finish with the same score, how are we ordered?
- Awards: Does that order decide a trophy, cash prize, qualification spot, or all three? Read the event’s award rules rather than inferring them from the order on the screen.
Some events leave players tied for a place. Others use an over-the-board playoff, particularly when a title or qualification spot is at stake. For FIDE-rated events, the FIDE Play-Off and Tie-Break Regulations, arts. 2–4 explain how event regulations specify the ranking method and how the ordered list is applied. In US Chess events, see Rule 34 and the posted event rules.
#2 — A worked example: two players on 4/5
Maya and Leon both finish 4/5 in this hypothetical five-round event. Maya beats Leon in Round 5. Each cell shows the player’s result and the opponent’s final tournament score in parentheses. Every game in this example was played.
| Player | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 | Round 5 | Final score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maya | Win (2) | Loss (3) | Win (3) | Win (2) | Beat Leon (4) | 4 |
| Leon | Win (3) | Win (1) | Win (3) | Win (2½) | Lost to Maya (4) | 4 |
Apply one method at a time:
| First method applied | Maya | Leon | Who ranks higher? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Modified Median (both above 50%) | 12 | 12½ | Leon |
| Solkoff or uncut Buchholz (all games played) | 14 | 13½ | Maya |
| Buchholz Cut-1 (all games played) | 12 | 12½ | Leon |
| Cumulative (unadjusted example) | 11 | 14 | Leon |
| Direct Encounter (head-to-head) | 1 | 0 | Maya |
| Sonneborn–Berger | 11 | 9½ | Maya |
There is no universal winner of the tie. If the posted order is Modified Median followed by Solkoff, Leon ranks ahead on the first criterion. Maya’s higher Solkoff never comes into play. If the event instead uses uncut Buchholz first, Maya is ahead. Now let’s see why.
#3 — US Chess: Modified Median, Solkoff and Cumulative
The 2026 US Chess rulebook, Rules 34E and 34E1–3, 34E9 lists the expected first four Swiss tie-breaks unless the tournament announced a different method: Modified Median, Solkoff, Cumulative, and Cumulative of Opposition, in that order.
Modified Median starts with your opponents’ adjusted final scores. In an event shorter than nine rounds, which score you drop depends on how you finished:
| Your score | Remove from the sum |
|---|---|
| Above 50% | Lowest opponent score |
| Exactly 50% | Highest and lowest opponent scores |
| Below 50% | Highest opponent score |
In events of nine rounds or more, remove two at each applicable end instead of one. In our example, both players are above 50%. Maya drops 2 from 14 and keeps 12; Leon drops 1 from 13½ and keeps 12½. Leon’s remaining four opponents together scored half a point more.
Solkoff adds the same adjusted opponent scores without dropping any. Maya’s total is 2 + 3 + 3 + 2 + 4 = 14. Leon’s is 3 + 1 + 3 + 2½ + 4 = 13½. Maya had the higher total before the cut. That is why Solkoff and Modified Median can reverse the order even though they start with the same information.
Cumulative adds your own running score as it stood after each round. Maya’s totals are 1, 1, 2, 3 and 4, adding to 11. Leon’s are 1, 2, 3, 4 and 4, adding to 14. Both won four games, but Leon scored his points earlier, so more of his points counted in more running totals. US Chess subtracts one point from this sum per unplayed win or full-point bye, and half a point per unplayed draw or half-point bye.
Cumulative of Opposition does not add opponents’ final scores as Solkoff does. Instead, calculate each opponent’s Cumulative tie-break under Rule 34E3 and add those values. You need those opponents’ round-by-round results, so you cannot calculate it from the two rows of our example alone.
#4 — FIDE: Buchholz, Direct Encounter and Sonneborn–Berger
FIDE does not require every tournament to use the same ordered list. Check the event regulations, then read the relevant formula in the FIDE Play-Off and Tie-Break Regulations effective March 1, 2026, arts. 4, 6, 8, 9 and 14.
Buchholz (BH) adds your opponents’ scores. With no unplayed rounds in our example, the figures match Solkoff: Maya 14 and Leon 13½. Buchholz Cut-1 (BH-C1) normally drops the lowest contribution, which gives Maya 12 and Leon 12½ here. Cut-2 normally drops the two lowest contributions, while Median-1 drops one from each end. The unplayed-round rules can change which contribution is removed. Under FIDE rules, the Buchholz family is not used for round robins.
Direct Encounter (DE) uses results among the tied players. If there are exactly two and they played a decisive game, as in our example, Maya’s win puts her first among them when this method is applied. If they drew or did not meet, it cannot separate that pair. With three or more tied players, the calculation is not simply “find two players who met.” When everyone in the tie has met, calculate their standings from those encounters and reapply the method to any still-tied subset. When games are missing in a Swiss, FIDE allows a rank to be assigned only if it is guaranteed whatever results those missing games might have produced. FIDE Article 6 also has rules for repeat encounters and forfeits. US Chess has its own head-to-head rule for multiway ties (34E5); do not substitute one procedure for the other.
Sonneborn–Berger (SB) measures what you scored against each opponent, not just whom you faced. Multiply each opponent’s final score by the points you earned against them, and add the products. In a played game, a win counts the full opponent score, a draw counts half, and a loss adds zero. Maya: 2 + 0 + 3 + 2 + 4 = 11. Leon: 3 + 1 + 3 + 2½ + 0 = 9½. Maya beat a 4-point opponent; Leon lost to one. Sonneborn–Berger is especially useful in a round robin because two tied players have the same set of other opponents and can be compared on how they scored against them. For the US Chess round-robin version, including its treatment of unplayed games, see Rule 34F. For FIDE events, consult Articles 15–16 when games are unplayed.
#5 — Why an unplayed round changes the math
The identical Solkoff and Buchholz numbers in our example depend on everyone playing. Apply their respective rules when there is a bye, forfeit, or withdrawal. Keep two perspectives separate: your own tie-break when you did not play, and your opponent’s tie-break when your score appears in their calculation.
US Chess Modified Median and Solkoff. An unplayed round on your own card contributes zero as an opponent entry. For people who actually played you, each of your unplayed rounds is valued at half a point when calculating your adjusted score for their tie-breaks. Your official tournament score does not change. That is different from the penalty used for Cumulative.
FIDE Swiss Buchholz and Sonneborn–Berger. For a player’s own unplayed round, 2026 FIDE Article 16 assigns a notional opponent based on that player’s final score, subject to a cap. For a forfeit the cap is the scheduled opponent’s adjusted score; in other categories the cap is the number of rounds multiplied by the points for a draw. The notional result follows the points actually awarded. For other players’ tie-breaks, the adjusted score is calculated separately: most unplayed results use the points awarded, but requested byes not followed by a round in which the player was available to play are treated as draws for this purpose. A requested bye in the last round is included in that rule. The term voluntary unplayed round includes a requested bye and a forfeit loss; a Buchholz Cut-1 calculation for a player with such a round cuts the lowest contribution from one of those rounds, which is not necessarily the lowest entry overall. Check for announced alternatives: Article 16.6 permits event rules to specify variations in advance.
For a compact example, suppose in a separate five-round event you earn 4/5 with three played wins, a played loss, and a full-point pairing bye. Assume the four opponents you actually played all completed their games and finished on 3, 3, 2, and 2. Under US Chess Solkoff, the bye adds zero to your 10-point opposition total. Under the default FIDE Buchholz rules it contributes 2½: your own final score is 4, but the non-forfeit cap is 5 × ½ = 2½. Your Buchholz is 12½. In both cases, your game-point score stays 4/5.
#6 — Standings, trophies and cash prizes
Suppose the event offers a first-place trophy and cash prizes of $150 for first and $50 for second. Two equally eligible players tie for first on game points, and there are no overlapping awards or published cash playoff provisions. Under the usual US Chess treatment, each receives $100; the higher tie-break can decide who takes the trophy. It does not automatically send the entire first-place cash amount to that player. A cash-deciding playoff is an exception when properly announced in detailed pre-tournament publicity. For overlapping class or place prizes, read the award restrictions and US Chess Class Prizes Explained. See US Chess Rules 32B, 32F and 34C. For a FIDE event’s prizes or qualification spots, consult that event’s regulations; a tiebreak formula alone does not tell you how its awards are allocated.
What to check at your next event: Confirm the announced tie-break order and the separate prize or qualification rules. After the last round, verify your game score and any byes or forfeits before comparing tie-breaks. If a number still looks wrong, tell the tournament director which result or type of bye you think is recorded incorrectly. That gives them something specific to check.
For organizers: publish the order, any unplayed-round variations, and which places or prizes need to be separated. Then make sure the software is using those settings. An unexplained “TB1” column is not a substitute for an announcement.
