My Child’s Chess Rating Isn’t Going Up. Are They Still Improving?

By GM Ulvi Bajarani, Founder and Head Coach of Azeri Chess Academy.

Imagine your child starts and ends the month with a US Chess rating near 900. Early in the month, they regularly left a knight or bishop undefended. In their latest games, they noticed those attacks but struggled to win an extra-pawn ending. The rating hasn’t moved much, but the games show that one problem is becoming less frequent and another is worth working on.

I would look at the games before changing the training plan. A US Chess rating reflects results and the strength of the opposition. It doesn’t tell you whether your child spotted a threat, considered a recapture, or used their clock well when the position got difficult. To see those changes, you need a few games you can replay.

Start with six comparable games

Choose three recent slow games as a starting point. Then look at three more after your child has had time to practice. Use roughly comparable time controls and note the strength of the opposition if you know it. If the second group was against much stronger players, or the only games you have are blitz, make a note rather than drawing a firm conclusion. Include wins and losses if you have both. A win can hide the same mistake as a loss.

Review one or two decisions from each game, not every move. Ask your child first: “What did you think your opponent would do?” Let them replay the move before opening an engine. If they didn’t record their clock time or can’t remember what they saw during the game, mark it unknown rather than guessing. Our game-review guide shows how to do this in more detail.

A flat rating can hide a useful change

Here is an illustrative example. In three slow games, a child makes four moves that leave a knight or bishop available to capture for free. Over the next three comparable games, they do it once. In the later games, they describe noticing the opponent’s threat before moving in two reviewed positions. Their rating stays close to 900.

I would call that encouraging evidence, not proof that the problem is solved. Six games are a small sample. I would keep the safety check in practice and look again in the next slow games. If the child is now reaching more playable endgames and repeatedly mishandling the same kind of pawn ending, that is a better candidate for the next lesson than simply assigning more puzzles.

The reverse can happen too. A child wins three games and gains rating, but keeps overlooking an immediate recapture. I would still work on the recapture. When results and decisions point in different directions, the games tell you what to teach next.

Look for changes you can point to

Fewer one-move losses of material. Count clear occasions when a move let the opponent win a piece immediately without adequate compensation, even if the opponent missed it. Count the initiating mistake once, rather than counting every consequence. Include a move number so you can find the position again. If games differ greatly in length, compare similar portions of each.

Better use of the clock. At one difficult decision, record the time remaining if you know it and ask why your child played when they did. A quick forced recapture and a quick move in a position with several threats are different decisions. Look for whether they are giving themselves time where it matters, rather than rewarding slow play on every move.

More attention to the opponent’s reply. Choose a position where the opponent had a serious check or capture. Ask your child what they saw during the game. Mark whether they considered the reply then, found it only in review, or aren’t sure. A move found afterward can guide practice, but it doesn’t show that the habit is already there at the board.

Choose one thing to practice

If the repeated mistake is leaving pieces undefended, take two positions from your child’s games. In each one, let them choose a move, then ask them to show the strongest immediate check or capture for the opponent. Use both a position where the move is safe and one where it fails. Your child should learn to tell the difference, rather than assume every position contains a trick.

Try the same check in the next few slow games. Afterward, ask for one move where they used it. Then decide together whether to keep practicing it or move to something else. The checks-and-captures lesson provides three positions you can use to get started.

Keep the progress sheet private and use it with your child, not as a report card. “You spotted the reply before moving here” tells them what to do again. “Your rating should be higher by now” doesn’t. If the record doesn’t show a clear pattern, collect a few more comparable games before overhauling the plan.

Six-Game Chess Progress Sheet

Use three starting games and three later games. For each game, review one or two decisions before giving your child hints. Download the printable progress sheet (PDF).

Compare three starting games with three later games.
GameDate, time control and opponent rating (if known)Free piece losses: count and key moveClock time left at a difficult move, and decisionOpponent’s reply: move and when noticed
1 (Starting)    
2 (Starting)    
3 (Starting)    
4 (Later)    
5 (Later)    
6 (Later)    

Reply key: S = saw it during the game; R = found it in review; ? = unsure. Use N/A when there was no useful example. Leave unknown clock times blank.

  • What improved or stayed the same? Which moves show it?
  • What might make these groups hard to compare?
  • What’s one practice task for the next few games?

For questions about which rating you’re seeing or when it updates, see US Chess Ratings for Parents. If you’d like help identifying what to practice next, request a free 15-minute online chess assessment. You can bring a game you’d like to discuss.

Scroll to Top